Albion's Neighborhood Café & Bar

What if your morning coffee turned into your favorite evening drink — all at the same table?

McFisties is Hamilton Street's hidden gem: a sunlit café by day, a warmly lit bar by night. Handcrafted drinks, fresh local ingredients, and a space that feels like home.

Explore the Menu Get Directions
Hamilton St., Albion
1 (585) 867-5309
Open Today: 7 AM – 11 PM
Scroll to explore
Warm interior of McFisties café with terracotta walls and natural light
Cozy bar counter at McFisties with artisan drinks
Fresh pastries and coffee at McFisties
Our Story

A place that feels like
coming home.

McFisties was born from a simple idea: why should good coffee and great company only happen at certain times of day? We opened our doors on Hamilton Street to create a space that breathes differently at different hours — quiet and golden in the morning, warm and buzzing in the evening.

Every cup is pulled with care, every pour is intentional, and every guest is treated like they've walked in next door to visit old friends. That's the McFisties way.

Locally Rooted

Proudly part of the Albion community, sourcing from nearby farms and producers whenever we can.

Day & Night

Café vibes from 7 AM to 5 PM, then the bar comes alive until 11 PM. Same table, different mood.

Made with Care

From single-origin beans to house-made syrups, nothing is rushed and nothing is ordinary.

What People Say

Loved by the
neighborhood.

"I come here every morning before work and it's become the best part of my day. The baristas remember my order and the pastries are unreal. This is what a neighborhood café should be."

Portrait of a smiling customer
Sarah M. Albion local

"The shift from café to bar is seamless. I'll grab a coffee during the day, then come back at 6 for a cocktail. The Albion Old Fashioned is dangerously good. Such a special spot."

Portrait of a smiling customer
David L. Regular visitor

"I hosted a small gathering here and the team was incredibly accommodating. The space is gorgeous — all those warm tones and natural light. Already planning my next visit."

Portrait of a smiling customer
Jenna R. Event host
Come Say Hi

We're waiting
for you.

Whether it's a quick coffee on your way to work or a long evening with good friends, there's always a spot for you at McFisties.

Address

Hamilton St.
Albion, New York

Hours

Mon–Thu: 7 AM – 10 PM
Fri–Sat: 7 AM – 11 PM
Sunday: 8 AM – 9 PM

Send Us a Message

Have a question, want to book a table, or just want to say hello? Drop us a line and we'll get back to you soon.

Is this your business?This is my business